Bug 427981

*** Bug 429477 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

*** Bug 430075 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

kde3/recommends:multimedia
kde3_multimedia/obsoletes:kde_multimedia < 11.0
kde3_multimedia/supplements:multimediaa
kde3_multimedia/extends:multimedia
kde3_multimedia/provides:kde_multimedia = 11.0


kde4/recommends:multimedia
kde4_multimedia/supplements:multimedia
kde4_multimedia/extends:multimedia

This should have worked. Do you have yast logs available? 

The provides "= 11.0" part doesn't look correct:

kde3/provides:kde = 11.0
kde3_admin/provides:kde_admin = 11.0
kde3_basis/provides:kde_basis = 11.0
kde3_basis_opt/provides:kde_basis_opt = 11.0
kde3_edutainment/provides:kde_edutainment = 11.0
kde3_games/provides:kde_games = 11.0
kde3_ide/provides:kde_ide = 11.0
kde3_imaging/provides:kde_imaging = 11.0
kde3_imaging_opt/provides:kde_imaging_opt = 11.0
kde3_internet/provides:kde_internet = 11.0
kde3_laptop/provides:kde_laptop = 11.0
kde3_multimedia/provides:kde_multimedia = 11.0
kde3_office/provides:kde_office = 11.0
kde3_office_opt/provides:kde_office_opt = 11.0
kde3_utilities/provides:kde_utilities = 11.0
kde3_utilities_opt/provides:kde_utilities_opt = 11.0
kde3_xgl/provides:kde_xgl = 11.0
kde3_yast/provides:kde_yast = 11.0
sw_management/provides:zmd = 11.0
sw_management_kde3/provides:sw_management_kde = 11.0

Installation logs show now hint why the patterns were not selected, only that they were not selected.

Btw, from patterns-openSUSE build log:

Package OpenOffice_org is missing
Package banshee-devel is missing
Package bluez-cups is missing
Package fast-user-switch-applet is missing
Package geronimo2 is missing
Package jre >= 1.5 is missing
Package php5-imap is missing
Package powersave is missing
Package qt3-static is missing
Package smartlink-softmodem is missing
Package vmware-kmp-pae is missing
Package yast2-pkg-bindings-devel-doc is missing

Installation logs show now hint why the patterns were not selected, only that they were not selected.

Btw, from patterns-openSUSE build log:

Package OpenOffice_org is missing
Package banshee-devel is missing
Package bluez-cups is missing
Package fast-user-switch-applet is missing
Package geronimo2 is missing
Package jre >= 1.5 is missing
Package php5-imap is missing
Package powersave is missing
Package qt3-static is missing
Package smartlink-softmodem is missing
Package vmware-kmp-pae is missing
Package yast2-pkg-bindings-devel-doc is missing

Could it be because of bug 427688?

*** Bug 430473 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

No, I don't think it has anything todo with bug 427688. The warnings/issues from patterns-openSUSE build log will be fixed later today.

Stano, could someone from the YaST teams take a look at this?

Stephan, we'll need your YaST logs attached to this bug.

Created attachment 242189 [details]
YaST log files of Beta 1 KDE4 desktop installation

Schubi, could you help, please?

Could you please add a solver testcase ?

Created attachment 242485 [details]
Requested solver test case

Hm, the dependencies looks correct:
<pattern>
        <name>kde4_multimedia</name>
        <supplements>
                <dep name='packageand(pattern:multimedia,pattern:kde4)' />
        </supplements>
</pattern>

Michael, could you please check it ?

No, it doesn't look correct. The syntax is packageand(pkg:pkg:pkg...), i.e.
packageand(pattern:multimedia:pattern:kde4). Oh wait, that can't work. Sorry no bonus. We need to fix the parser for this.

(A ',' character can't be used because rpm splits the dependencies at commas...).

Plus, patterns don't get installed so supplements really don't work well. Maybe we can support them better in some future version.

This is not INVALID, this bug happens still with Beta 2 and it's a regression compared to 11.0.

hence reopening

As suspected (but disputed in comment 9 ;-) installing libdvdread4 from online repository first fixes this problem.

*** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 427688 ***

Still, the supplements can't work and probably never has. Beware.